A branch of BeisVaad.blogspot.com I'm on AOL, eliezere. In Marlboro, NJ, I saw that the Rav asks five questions before Krias HaTorah. Some are simple. Others are carefully crafted to spotlight things that most people do not notice, but if they pay attention will they realize the answer. They do not involve Rashi or Targum or anything other than paying serious attention.
Friday, June 15, 2018
Shavu'os
I'm putting this up in the hopes that someone can help me make something useful about it. I pointed out to my shiur that the mitzva to place lamb between two pieces of bread is well known on Pesach, according to Hillel. Less well known is that the same mitzva pertains to Shavuos. Answer- the tnufa of the kvasim between the Shtei Halechem, both before and after shchita. That's fine, and clever enough, but it would be so much better if I could figure out a way to say that there's also such a concept on Sukkos. So far, nothing.
Thursday, June 7, 2018
Shlach.
Not riddles, just questions. Since they're not mine, I am providing the answers.
This is borrowed from Rabbi Rand of Hebrew Theological College of Skokie, IL. The website is Here.
Questions for Thought and Study
What reason did Bnei Yisrael use to convince Moshe that they should send spies to
Canaan? Was it a valid reason?
See Ohr HaChaim 13:2
Why does the Torah need to repeat in Pasuk 13:16 that these were “the names - zFnW§ ”
of the men who were chosen as spies?
See Ibn Ezra 13:16
If Canaan was filled with giants, as the spies reported, how could the spies claim that
the land was uninhabitable and its produce was unhealthy?
See Ramban 13:32
Did normal-sized people live in Canaan? If yes, why were the spies as “grasshoppers”
(13:33) in the eyes of the Canaanite giants?
See Ohr HaChaim 13:33
What was “m¨lv¦ - their protection” (literally “shade”) that Hashem said He would
remove from Canaan so that Bnei Yisrael would conquer them?
See Rashi, Ibn Ezra and Ramban to 14:9
Answers:
Bnei Yisrael convinced Moshe that the Canaanites knew that Bnei Yisrael were going to conquer
them. In preparation, Canaan was burying all their valuables. Spies should therefore be sent to
uncover (see Devarim 1:22 - "ExR§ g§ i©e§") these hiding places. This was a valid reason, and it convinced
Moshe. However, they really lacked faith in Hashem, which is why the tragedy ofthe spies occurred.
These were their names, and they would not change, as Yehoshua’s name was changed.
The spies claimed that the air and the produce of Canaan were so abnormally heavy that
normal-sized people could not survive.
Even the normal-sized people in Canaan were larger than the average member of Bnei Yisrael.
The spies appeared small, even compared to the people of Canaan of average height.
Rashi says that the righteous individuals of Canaan had died, so the Canaanites were no longer
protected through their merit. Ibn Ezra says that "m¨lv¦ " is like battle gear, and the Canaanites feared
Bnei Yisrael as one who is at battle without any battle gear. Ramban says that someone who is
destined to not see his shadow ("m¨lv¦ ") from the moon on Hoshana Rabbah night is destined to die
that year.
This is borrowed from Rabbi Rand of Hebrew Theological College of Skokie, IL. The website is Here.
Questions for Thought and Study
What reason did Bnei Yisrael use to convince Moshe that they should send spies to
Canaan? Was it a valid reason?
See Ohr HaChaim 13:2
Why does the Torah need to repeat in Pasuk 13:16 that these were “the names - zFnW§ ”
of the men who were chosen as spies?
See Ibn Ezra 13:16
If Canaan was filled with giants, as the spies reported, how could the spies claim that
the land was uninhabitable and its produce was unhealthy?
See Ramban 13:32
Did normal-sized people live in Canaan? If yes, why were the spies as “grasshoppers”
(13:33) in the eyes of the Canaanite giants?
See Ohr HaChaim 13:33
What was “m¨lv¦ - their protection” (literally “shade”) that Hashem said He would
remove from Canaan so that Bnei Yisrael would conquer them?
See Rashi, Ibn Ezra and Ramban to 14:9
Answers:
Bnei Yisrael convinced Moshe that the Canaanites knew that Bnei Yisrael were going to conquer
them. In preparation, Canaan was burying all their valuables. Spies should therefore be sent to
uncover (see Devarim 1:22 - "ExR§ g§ i©e§") these hiding places. This was a valid reason, and it convinced
Moshe. However, they really lacked faith in Hashem, which is why the tragedy ofthe spies occurred.
These were their names, and they would not change, as Yehoshua’s name was changed.
The spies claimed that the air and the produce of Canaan were so abnormally heavy that
normal-sized people could not survive.
Even the normal-sized people in Canaan were larger than the average member of Bnei Yisrael.
The spies appeared small, even compared to the people of Canaan of average height.
Rashi says that the righteous individuals of Canaan had died, so the Canaanites were no longer
protected through their merit. Ibn Ezra says that "m¨lv¦ " is like battle gear, and the Canaanites feared
Bnei Yisrael as one who is at battle without any battle gear. Ramban says that someone who is
destined to not see his shadow ("m¨lv¦ ") from the moon on Hoshana Rabbah night is destined to die
that year.
Subscribe to:
Comments (Atom)
Vayeilech 2025
1. Find a remez for techiyas hameisim in the parsha. Corollary: why is it that we never find explicit mentions of kiyum haneshama, much less...
-
-
I hope readers will offer more good questions that I can incorporate. Remember, I don't want questions that require knowledge of Rashi...
-
1. What event began with the East Wind and ended with the West Wind. 2. Two mitzvos in this parsha are described as "אות." What ...